That Thing America Needs to Achieve Soccer Greatness
September 14th, 2008 Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »There is a lot of talk about soccer programs and what the USA must do different to become a true soccer nation. Usually I hear this talk couched in terms of competitive success - but before we ever declare “US Soccer” a success, I think we’ll need to know what it is.
Soccer fans know what Brazilian soccer looks like, we know what Italian soccer looks like, what Spanish soccer looks like, what German soccer looks like, what Argentinian soccer looks like, and the list goes on. Every great soccer nation has a style of soccer that is the basis for their success, but also exists as an end in itself. It is part of their national identity.
Brazilians would rather lose, I think, than lose their samba and play boring 9 men behind the ball. It is hard for me to imagine Italy happy with any victory where their defense gave away many goals.
Today I am watching some 13 year old boys play a match and a few of us soccer dads are talking. One of the dads grew up playing soccer in Mexico, another grew up playing in Japan, our sons work together on the pitch against the other team. We talk about the qualities of German soccer, of Italian and Mexican soccer. What is US soccer? A mix, is all we can figure.
If we study to become a great mix I fear we will not achieve greatness in any aspect of the game. Without consistent greatness in some aspect of our play, we cannot become a great soccer nation.
Today the US style of soccer seems simply based on whatever strengths our better players happen to have. That approach seems more destined to yield junk than jamabalaya.
Mix together: a direct forward with pace, a very physical center back, some midfielders who play direct, some who don’t, season with coaching… OK, some games it works depending upon who plays and who the competition is, but crunching tackles and joga bonito don’t work well together. You can add great Brazilian players (e.g. Robinho) to an English team (Manchester City), but that doesn’t make it Barcelona FC.
If we want to be a great soccer nation, there should be more method than madness, more plan than luck, there should player development in a style of play we want to play.
What is the US style of soccer? What should it be?